Actor and playwright Cole Escola found themselves in a reflective mood following their Tony nomination for the role of Mary Todd Lincoln in the play 'Oh, Mary!'. The production, which Escola also wrote, garnered five Tony nominations, including best play. This satirical reimagining of Mary Todd Lincoln originally premiered Off-Broadway in 2024 before transferring to Broadway. During its run, Escola took a break, allowing Betty Gilpin and Tituss Burgess to temporarily assume the lead role. Upon returning to the show, Escola expressed gratitude for the recognition and pride in the work they have created with their team.
Escola’s journey with 'Oh, Mary!' began over a decade ago, inspired by the question of how Abe Lincoln's assassination might have been perceived differently by his wife. The result is an audacious portrayal of Mary Todd Lincoln as a cabaret singer with a penchant for drinking. Initially staged at the Lucille Lortel Theatre, the play was extended twice before moving to Broadway in July 2024. Despite taking time off during the winter, Escola returned to the production in April, bringing renewed energy to the character.
In conversations about their first Tony nomination, Escola revealed feeling both emotional and grounded, striving to maintain focus on upcoming performances. They admitted that celebrating such an occasion might be daunting for Mary Todd Lincoln herself, given her character’s nature. Reflecting on the transfer to Broadway, Escola marveled at the evolution from humble beginnings at La MaMa, where hopes were set on merely extending the show by two weeks.
Upon returning to the role after a hiatus, Escola experienced relief as the character seemed to flow effortlessly back into their performance. Witnessing other actors portray Mary Todd Lincoln provided them with a fresh perspective, likening it to watching animated versions of their creations come to life. Observing Betty Gilpin’s interpretation marked Escola's first full viewing of the production, revealing elements like lighting designs previously unseen while performing.
The future of 'Oh, Mary!' remains uncertain but hopeful, with aspirations for further adaptations or additional casts playing key roles. Escola humorously acknowledged the irony of competing against George Clooney in the same category, yet expressed excitement about celebrating alongside fellow nominees and contributors. In closing, Escola reaffirmed their deep affection for American theater, appreciating the opportunities it has afforded them.
As the Tony Awards approach, Escola anticipates a mix of nerves and exhilaration, grateful for the recognition and inclusion in this prestigious season. Their heartfelt connection to the project shines through, highlighting not only their talent but also their dedication to the craft of storytelling within the theatrical realm.