In a recent controversy, the film Conclave, which has garnered significant attention and accolades, including winning Best Screenplay at the 2025 Golden Globes, has faced criticism from former Fox News host Megyn Kelly. Kelly accused the film of being "anti-Catholic" due to its plot twist involving an intersex pope. Screenwriter Peter Straughan responded to these allegations, defending the film's message and intentions. The film, directed by Edward Berger, is based on Robert Harris's novel and explores the intense process of electing a new pope. Despite the backlash, the movie continues to receive praise for its performances and narrative depth.

The Controversy Unfolds: A Closer Look at the Film and Its Critics

In the heart of Hollywood’s award season, the film Conclave emerged as a standout, capturing the Best Screenplay award at the prestigious Golden Globes ceremony held in Los Angeles. However, just hours before the event, a storm of controversy erupted when Megyn Kelly, a well-known media figure, voiced her strong disapproval of the film on social media platform X. Kelly, who expressed disgust over the film’s portrayal of the Catholic Church, particularly criticized the unexpected revelation that the newly elected pope is intersex.

The film, set against the backdrop of a secretive conclave where cardinals gather to choose the next pontiff, delves into themes of power, faith, and human frailty. Directed by Edward Berger and featuring a star-studded cast including Ralph Fiennes, Stanley Tucci, and John Lithgow, Conclave has been praised for its nuanced exploration of complex characters. Yet, Kelly’s comments sparked a heated debate about the film’s intent and its representation of Catholicism.

When asked about Kelly’s accusations during the Golden Globes press conference, screenwriter Peter Straughan firmly defended the film. He emphasized that the story was not meant to be anti-Catholic but rather to highlight the church’s spiritual essence—a core value he believes is central to Catholic teachings. Straughan also pointed out that the film aims to explore the humanity of its characters, showcasing their struggles and moral dilemmas without vilifying the institution itself.

Kelly’s critique extended beyond the plot twist, accusing the film of portraying cardinals as morally bankrupt and suggesting that only the intersex pope and one cardinal were redeemable. She further argued that such a portrayal would not be tolerated if targeted at other religious groups, raising questions about the treatment of Christian and Catholic figures in media.

A Reflection on Artistic Expression and Religious Sensitivity

From a journalistic perspective, this controversy highlights the delicate balance between artistic expression and respect for religious beliefs. While Conclave seeks to provoke thought and challenge preconceived notions, it also serves as a reminder of the importance of sensitivity when addressing deeply held convictions. Director Edward Berger’s statement that disagreement is a positive force in dialogue underscores the value of open conversation and diverse viewpoints. Ultimately, this incident invites us to reflect on how we engage with controversial topics and whether we can appreciate art while maintaining mutual respect for all beliefs.