A transgender storyline was reportedly cut from Pixar's Win or Lose series, as reported by The Hollywood Reporter and Variety. This move came before the series' February 2025 release date. A Disney spokesperson confirmed the removal, stating that the character would still be part of the series but without the specific lines that referenced gender identity. This decision has drawn attention and sparked conversations about the portrayal of diverse characters in animated content.
When it comes to animated shows for younger audiences, Disney recognizes that many parents prefer to discuss certain subjects with their children at their own pace. This led to the removal of the transgender storyline, aiming to respect parents' wishes and provide a more suitable viewing experience. However, this decision has also faced criticism from those who advocate for more inclusive storytelling.
Win or Lose was created, written, and directed by Carrie Hobson and Michael Yates. Each episode follows a different member of a co-ed softball team as they prepare for the championship game. The official synopsis describes the series as revealing what it feels like to be in the shoes of eight different characters in the week leading up to the big game, with unique and emotional animated perspectives.
Disney's Chief Creative Officer, Pete Docter, described the show as a major, first-of-its-kind tentpole series that showcases the studio's strengths in bold, imaginative storytelling and relatable characters. The series aims to bring a diverse range of experiences to the screen and connect with audiences on a deeper level.
Disney has a history of releasing productions with LGBTQ+ storylines, such as Agatha All Along, All of Us Strangers, Next Goal Wins, Fire Island, and Pose. These stories have added diversity to their content but have not been without pushback.
In 2023, a Florida teacher was investigated for showing her fifth-grade class Strange World, which featured Disney's first openly gay character. The "Don't Say Gay" bill, which restricted the discussion of LGBTQ topics, was a source of contention between Gov. Ron DeSantis and Disney. DeSantis expanded the bill to cover grades 4 through 12, leading to a feud between the two.
In response to the bill, Disney condemned it and expressed their desire for its repeal. In retaliation, DeSantis took over the oversight district and fought Disney on various issues, including tax exemptions and their internal services. A lawsuit was filed, and a settlement was reached in June 2024.
Win or Lose is set to premiere on Disney+ on February 19, 2025. Despite the controversy surrounding the transgender storyline cut, the series continues to generate excitement among fans. It will offer a unique look at the lives of the softball team members and their journey towards the championship.
As Disney continues to explore diverse storylines and navigate through various challenges, Win or Lose will be a significant addition to their portfolio. It remains to be seen how the series will be received and how it will contribute to the ongoing conversation about representation and inclusivity in animation.