In the world of horror, toys often serve as conduits for both nostalgia and terror. Osgood Perkins' latest film, The Monkey, delves into this duality by exploring the dark side of childhood through a cursed toy. Based on Stephen King's 1980 short story, the film follows twin brothers Hal and Bill Shelburn, whose lives are upended by a malevolent toy monkey. Initially perceived as an innocent plaything, the Jolly Chimp soon reveals its sinister nature, causing a series of tragic events. Decades later, the adult Shelburns must confront their childhood fears once more. This narrative structure echoes themes found in King’s other works, particularly It. While the film attempts to stretch a single idea across two distinct timelines, it offers strong performances and a mix of horror and dark humor.

The film opens with the Shelburn twins living under the care of their single mother Lois. Played by Tatiana Maslany, Lois brings a cynical yet protective presence to the household. The early scenes focus on the dynamics between Hal and Bill, where Hal's meekness contrasts sharply with Bill's cruel demeanor. The introduction of the Jolly Chimp adds an eerie layer to the family life, with its unsettling grin and piercing eyes hinting at its malevolent intentions. As the toy begins to exert its influence, the brothers experience a series of unexplained tragedies that force them to take drastic measures, including disposing of the monkey in a well. These early moments establish the deceitful and manipulative nature of the toy, playing on the darkest desires of those around it.

Years pass, and the story transitions to the adult lives of Hal and Bill, now portrayed by Theo James. The second half of the film becomes more complex, introducing multiple characters and exploring the evolving rules of the Jolly Chimp's curse. Despite the increased complexity, the film maintains its black comedic tone, culminating in several gory and spectacular deaths. Theo James delivers dual performances that highlight the contrasting personalities of Hal and Bill, adding depth to their character arcs. Additionally, the film showcases Osgood Perkins' ability to blend psychological horror with unexpected humor, creating a unique viewing experience that is both chilling and entertaining.

Ultimately, The Monkey presents a compelling exploration of childhood trauma and its lasting impact on adulthood. The film's first half successfully captures the innocence and fear of youth, while the second half ventures into more chaotic territory, juggling numerous characters and plot points. Through strong performances and a distinctive directorial style, Perkins crafts a narrative that, despite its messiness, resonates with audiences who appreciate a blend of horror and dark comedy. The film serves as a reminder that some childhood terrors never truly fade away.