The Cult of Popularity: Debunking the Myth of "Cult Films"

In the world of cinema, the term "cult film" has become a subject of much debate and misunderstanding. While some movies are undoubtedly embraced by a devoted following, the criteria for what constitutes a true cult classic are often blurred. In this article, we'll explore the true nature of cult films and uncover the surprising truth behind some of the most popular movies that are often mistakenly labeled as such.

Unveiling the Secrets of Cult Cinema

The Elusive Definition of a Cult Film

The concept of a "cult film" is often shrouded in mystery, with no clear-cut definition that everyone can agree on. However, as Ernest Mathijs, the co-editor of The Cult Film Reader, explains in Cineaste Magazine, a true cult film is one that "becomes one by accident, through a public reception that is celebrated in a sectarian way." This means that a cult film is not born as such, but rather, it gradually develops a devoted following over time, often after an initial lukewarm or even hostile reception.

The Myth of Intentional Cult Films

One of the common misconceptions about cult films is that they can be deliberately created. However, as the article points out, "You can't set out to make a cult film, because a cult film is made by an audience — and usually by one that discovers it gradually after an underwhelming initial release." This means that the true essence of a cult film lies in its organic, grassroots-level popularity, rather than any conscious effort to cultivate a niche following.

Debunking the "Cult Film" Label

The article presents a list of 12 popular movies that are often mistakenly labeled as "cult films." These films, despite their widespread acclaim and commercial success, do not fit the criteria of a true cult classic. As the article states, "Disagree if you'd like; to me, none of these are cult films." This highlights the importance of understanding the nuanced nature of cult cinema and not simply applying the label to any movie that has a dedicated fan base.

The Allure of Cult Classics

While the term "cult film" may be overused and misapplied, the allure of true cult classics is undeniable. These movies often possess a unique charm, a subversive spirit, or a quirky sensibility that resonates with a specific audience. They become more than just films; they become cultural touchstones, fostering a sense of community and shared experience among their devoted fans.

Embracing the Diversity of Cinema

Ultimately, the discussion around "cult films" serves as a reminder that the world of cinema is vast and diverse. While some movies may achieve mainstream success, others may find their niche in the hearts of a dedicated few. By understanding the true nature of cult cinema, we can appreciate the rich tapestry of filmmaking and the many ways in which movies can captivate and inspire audiences.