A recent study has delved into the portrayal of Jewish characters in contemporary scripted television, revealing a concerning lack of diversity and perpetuation of harmful stereotypes. Conducted by the Media Impact Project with support from the Jewish Institute for Television & Cinema (JITC) Hollywood Bureau, the research underscores the importance of nuanced and humanizing depictions of Jewish Americans in media. By analyzing 49 episodes across 15 shows aired between 2021 and 2022, the study highlights the need for more inclusive and accurate representation to combat rising antisemitism.
The findings indicate that the vast majority of Jewish characters depicted on screen are white, with minimal representation of Jews from diverse backgrounds such as Black, Asian, or Middle Eastern communities. Additionally, portrayals of Orthodox Judaism are often limited and frequently present negative or stereotypical views. The study also notes that only a small fraction of Jewish characters reference their faith or cultural identity in dialogue, despite being identified as Jewish. These observations emphasize the need for more authentic and varied storytelling that reflects the true diversity within the Jewish community.
One of the most striking revelations is the prevalence of outdated tropes associating Jews with wealth and power. Thirty percent of Jewish characters were depicted as affluent, with many holding elite positions in media, entertainment, and other influential sectors. This reinforces centuries-old stereotypes that have historically fueled antisemitic sentiments. The researchers argue that such portrayals not only misrepresent the reality of Jewish life but also contribute to a broader societal misunderstanding of Jewish identity.
To address these issues, the study offers several recommendations aimed at improving the visibility and authenticity of Jewish characters on screen. It calls for storytellers to elevate untold Jewish narratives, celebrate Jewish pride and joy, and embrace diversity in all its forms. Furthermore, it advocates for giving voice to Orthodox Jews and depicting them as everyday individuals rather than isolated or criminalized figures. These changes are essential for fostering greater empathy and understanding, ultimately helping to mitigate the rise of antisemitism.
The urgency of this issue cannot be overstated. With antisemitic incidents increasing significantly in both the United States and Canada, the role of media in shaping public perception becomes even more critical. The study’s authors emphasize that the events leading up to the current surge in antisemitism highlight the need for responsible and thoughtful representation in entertainment. By implementing the study's recommendations, the industry can play a pivotal role in promoting a more inclusive and compassionate society.