Set against the backdrop of changing musical landscapes, Sarah Seltzer's debut novel explores the lives of two fictional sisters who rise to fame in the 1960s folk music scene. The narrative delves into the complex relationships between Judie and Sylvia Zingerman, their musical journey, and the impact on subsequent generations. As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that this is not just a tale of success but also one of personal struggles and the lasting echoes of past decisions. The novel transitions from the vibrant streets of Greenwich Village to the rebellious energy of the 1990s Riot Girl movement through the eyes of Emma Cantor, Judie's daughter. Through rich character development and poignant storytelling, Seltzer weaves a tapestry of music, memory, and identity.

In the early 1960s, the world of folk music was undergoing a transformation. Bob Dylan may have been the face of this era, but Seltzer crafts her own universe where her characters can thrive independently. Young Judie Zingerman flees her suburban life for the bohemian allure of Greenwich Village. There, she encounters Dave Cantor, an established musician who later becomes her husband, and Eamon Foley, an Irish artist whose fleeting presence leaves an indelible mark on her life. As Judie and her sister Sylvia form a successful duo, their music captures the spirit of the times. However, at the peak of their career, Judie makes a sudden and unexpected decision to disband the group, leaving behind a legacy of unanswered questions.

Decades later, the focus shifts to Emma Cantor, the daughter of Judie and Dave. Despite her mother's reservations about pursuing a career in music, Emma plunges headfirst into the industry. Her rise to prominence in the Riot Girl movement of the 1990s parallels her mother's earlier journey. Through Emma's experiences, the novel delves deeper into the reasons behind Judie's abrupt departure from the stage. The narrative explores the nuances of family dynamics, the weight of past choices, and the power of music to bridge generational divides. Seltzer masterfully juxtaposes these timelines, revealing how memories and interpretations can diverge dramatically.

Beyond the glitz and glamour often associated with musical stardom, Seltzer's prose offers a more introspective look at the challenges faced by her characters. The novel touches on themes of trauma, resilience, and artistic integrity. Rather than focusing solely on the highs of fame, Seltzer delves into the gritty realities of creating music and the personal sacrifices that come with it. The sisters' father, Hyman, adds another layer to the narrative, challenging stereotypes of traditional Jewish families. His support for the arts, including building a home studio, highlights the complexity of familial relationships and the unexpected ways in which parents can influence their children's paths.

The novel concludes with a reflection on the enduring power of music to shape lives and legacies. Through the voices of Judie, Sylvia, and Emma, Seltzer creates a compelling exploration of identity, memory, and the unbreakable bonds between generations. The richly drawn characters and evocative storytelling leave readers longing for more, making this novel a memorable and thought-provoking read. Its potential for adaptation into a television series, complete with an original soundtrack, only adds to its appeal.