Movies
Reimagining Cinema: The Perils and Potential of Year-End Lists
2025-01-02
In the world of film criticism, year-end lists have become a ubiquitous tradition. These compilations aim to distill the cinematic essence of a year into neatly organized rankings. Yet, as Elena Gorfinkel argues in her provocative essay "Against Lists," such exercises often fall short of their noble intentions. Instead, they can perpetuate superficiality and commodification. This article explores the complexities of this annual ritual, questioning its value while celebrating the films that truly left an indelible mark.

Embrace the Unlisted: Discover Films Beyond Rankings

The allure of best-of lists is undeniable. They promise clarity amid the chaos of countless releases. However, these lists can inadvertently reinforce biases and overlook gems that don’t fit into preconceived categories. Gorfinkel’s critique challenges us to reconsider our relationship with cinema, urging a more holistic appreciation of diverse narratives and artistic expressions.

In today’s fast-paced media landscape, the pressure to produce early and definitive lists has never been greater. Publications and platforms scramble to capture attention, often at the expense of thorough evaluation. Critics are expected to deliver comprehensive assessments before they’ve had the chance to fully engage with the material. This rush undermines the depth and nuance that make film criticism valuable.

The Art of Inclusivity Without Lists

True inclusivity in film appreciation means embracing a wide spectrum of cinematic experiences without succumbing to the checklist mentality. When critics attempt to create all-encompassing lists, they risk reducing complex works to mere entries. Instead, fostering a culture that celebrates varied forms of storytelling allows for a richer understanding of global cinema.

Consider the films that defy easy categorization. From masterpieces like Dry Grasses, which captures the melancholy of Turkish Kurdistan, to the enigmatic plots of Bertrand Bonello’s The Beast and Coma, each offers unique insights into human nature and societal issues. By focusing on these individual narratives, we can appreciate the artistry and innovation that define contemporary filmmaking.

Critical Reflections on Distribution Practices

The mechanics of film distribution play a significant role in shaping year-end discussions. Qualifying runs, designed to generate buzz and awards recognition, can feel like a marketing ploy rather than a genuine effort to highlight quality work. Critics are often caught between the desire to be comprehensive and the practical limitations of time and access.

This tension is particularly evident in the way films are promoted during the holiday season. While some movies benefit from strategic releases, others may be overlooked simply because they don’t align with industry expectations. It’s essential to recognize and support films that challenge conventional norms, such as Zach Clark’s The Becomers, which reimagines sci-fi tropes with a fresh perspective.

A New Era of Filmmaking

The past few years have seen remarkable advancements in cinema, driven by visionary directors who push boundaries and explore new territories. Alice Rohrwacher’s La Chimera transports viewers to the 1980s tombaroli underworld, blending historical context with timeless themes of longing and identity. Similarly, Radu Jude’s Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World offers a scathing critique of modern filmmaking through unconventional narrative techniques.

These films not only entertain but also provoke thought and dialogue. They invite audiences to question established paradigms and consider alternative viewpoints. Whether it’s the haunting beauty of Eureka or the philosophical musings of Evil Does Not Exist, each work contributes to a broader conversation about the role of cinema in society.

Beyond the List: Embracing Cinematic Diversity

Ultimately, the value of film lies in its ability to transcend lists and rankings. By focusing on the intrinsic qualities of each movie, we can cultivate a deeper appreciation for the art form. This approach encourages exploration beyond mainstream offerings, leading to discoveries of hidden treasures like Here or Janet Planet.

In a world saturated with metrics and algorithms, Gorfinkel’s message resonates more than ever. Let us celebrate the richness and diversity of cinema without the constraints of rigid lists. Through thoughtful reflection and open-mindedness, we can honor the true spirit of filmmaking and the stories it tells.

More Stories
see more