Movies
Reimagining the Setting: Why Carry-On Should Have Stayed Closer to Home
2025-01-02
During a well-deserved break, I had the opportunity to dive into some of the 2024 films that had previously slipped my attention. Among these was Netflix’s latest thriller, "Carry-On," directed by Jaume Collet-Serra. While the film certainly delivers on suspense and action, it left me with a lingering question about its setting choices. Specifically, why did Ethan Kopek (Taron Egerton) choose LAX over Newark Liberty International Airport? This seemingly minor detail sparked a deeper reflection on how the film's narrative could have been enriched by staying closer to New Jersey roots.

A Fresh Perspective on Location Choices in Thrillers

In today’s cinematic landscape, location plays a pivotal role in shaping a film’s atmosphere and character development. By opting for LAX, "Carry-On" misses an opportunity to leverage the rich tapestry of New Jersey’s unique culture and history. Imagine the tension building not just within airport terminals but also against the backdrop of a state known for its resilience and distinct regional identities. This shift could have added layers to the protagonist’s journey, making his escape more symbolic and emotionally resonant.

The Power of Proximity: Exploring Local Narratives

Newark Liberty International Airport, with its three-terminal layout, offers a claustrophobic yet dynamic environment that would have perfectly complemented the film’s tense storyline. The reduced space could heighten the sense of urgency and confinement, amplifying the psychological drama. Moreover, situating the story closer to New York City allows for seamless integration of urban elements, enhancing Nora’s career aspirations without stretching the plot too thin.

This proximity also invites exploration of New Jersey’s diverse regions, from the bustling northern areas to the quieter central zones. Such a setting could introduce nuanced subplots involving local characters and landmarks, enriching the narrative and providing viewers with a fresh perspective on familiar territory. It’s a subtle yet powerful way to ground the film in reality while adding depth to its fictional world.

Cultural Nuances: A Deeper Dive into Regional Identity

New Jersey is a state steeped in history and cultural diversity. From its vibrant cities to its picturesque landscapes, each region carries its own stories and traditions. Ethan Kopek’s background as the son of a mall guard and a former track star in New Brunswick adds layers to his character. Moving him to Newark would emphasize themes of identity and belonging, exploring how past experiences shape future decisions. This alignment with the protagonist’s roots can create a stronger emotional connection with the audience.

Furthermore, incorporating New Jersey references can pay homage to the state’s contributions to popular culture. Whether through music, sports, or everyday life, these nods can resonate with both locals and newcomers, fostering a sense of community and shared heritage. In essence, this approach transforms the setting from a mere backdrop into an integral part of the story, enhancing its overall impact.

Filmmaking Logistics: Beyond Practical Considerations

While practical reasons such as filming locations often influence production choices, they shouldn’t overshadow the potential for richer storytelling. Despite "Carry-On" being filmed in New Orleans, the decision to set it at LAX seems driven more by convenience than creative vision. A shift to Newark could challenge filmmakers to think outside the box, leveraging the unique characteristics of the location to elevate the narrative.

Moreover, embracing lesser-known settings can open doors to innovative cinematography and set design. The gritty realism of Newark’s streets, juxtaposed with the sleek modernity of its airport, offers a visual feast that can captivate audiences. This blend of old and new not only enhances the film’s aesthetic appeal but also provides opportunities for fresh storytelling angles, keeping viewers engaged and invested.

Beyond Criticism: Appreciating the Film’s Merits

Despite my musings on location, "Carry-On" remains a compelling thriller that delivers excitement and intrigue. Taron Egerton’s portrayal of Ethan Kopek is both intense and relatable, while Jason Bateman’s enigmatic presence adds depth to the plot. The film’s ability to draw comparisons to other iconic works, such as Toy Story 2, showcases its versatility and charm. Ultimately, whether set in LAX or Newark, "Carry-On" stands as a testament to the power of storytelling and the universal appeal of a well-crafted narrative.

More Stories
see more