In We Live in Time, Andrew Garfield and Florence Pugh shine in their roles as Tobias and Almut. Their chemistry is palpable from the very first scene, where Almut, an ultra-competitive super chef played by Florence Pugh, hits Tobias, a newly divorced man played by Andrew Garfield, with her car and takes him to the hospital. This meet-cute sets the stage for a love story that is both charming and challenging.
As the story unfolds, we witness the ups and downs of their relationship. Tobias is more eager to have children than Almut, creating early friction between them. However, their love grows stronger as they work together to overcome their differences and solve the problems that come their way. With a ticking clock against her head, Almut realizes that she is running out of time and must achieve her goals in a short period to leave a lasting memory for her daughter.
The film's narrative is less about a linear story and more about recollections. It relies on hindsight and memories to create its magic, making us reflect on our own lives and relationships. While the Richard Curtis influence is evident at times, the film never truly tries to do anything new. It sticks to the familiar tropes of romance and heartbreak, but with a unique touch.
However, there are moments when the film struggles to connect with the audience. Almut's actions often feel unconvincing, as if she is not a fully developed character. We find ourselves asking why we should care about these characters and their story. The lack of depth in her character detracts from the overall impact of the film.
Amidst the somber atmosphere of the film, there are moments of humor that provide some relief. The gas station scene, where strangers help a woman about to give birth, is a prime example. The unique awkwardness of the situation is both hilarious and deeply moving. It shows the film's ability to blend humor and seriousness in a way that is not always successful.
Garfield's character often feels like he is making sacrifices at every turn, and we don't get to know much about his personality. This lack of character development limits our connection with him and makes it harder to fully invest in the story. Despite these flaws, the film brings a sense of maturity to its handling of grief, with Garfield delivering a powerful performance.
One of the film's biggest shortcomings is the lack of charisma from Garfield and Pugh. As two of the most charismatic working actors in the industry, they had the potential to make this film truly special. Their performances are solid, but they could have been more engaging and captivating.
If Garfield and Pugh had been allowed to let their charisma shine through, this film could have had a greater impact. As it is, it is a missed opportunity to create a truly memorable romantic drama.