In a recent contest, nearly 3,000 teenagers shared their opinions on various forms of entertainment, ranging from TV shows and films to books, music, art, and dance. Their lists highlight both what to enjoy and what to avoid. These young cultural curators provided insights into iconic teen TV dramas of the 2000s, the worst high school dance songs, and contemporary novels that reinvent classics. The "My List" Contest reimagined the traditional Student Review Contest by inviting participants to create curated lists rather than single reviews, sparking creativity and engagement.

The winners showcased innovative concepts, offering diverse perspectives on media and culture. Additionally, the imaginative titles of runners-up and honorable mentions invite exploration and debate. This initiative not only celebrates the work of young critics but also encourages interaction through comments, allowing readers to express appreciation or disagreement with the choices made.

Revolutionizing Reviews: From Single Critiques to Curated Lists

The transformation of the Student Review Contest into the "My List" format marks a significant shift in how teenagers engage with cultural criticism. Instead of focusing on individual works, participants were encouraged to compile lists of three to five items around a chosen theme. This approach fosters deeper reflection and comparison, as it requires identifying common threads among different pieces of media while articulating why they resonate—or fail to resonate—with the curator.

This new format allows for a richer expression of personal taste and critical thinking. For instance, one winner crafted a list of Ariana Grande songs that encapsulate relationship struggles, demonstrating how modern pop music can serve as a vehicle for emotional storytelling. Another participant delved into Amy Sherald's artwork, blending classical techniques with contemporary elements to create something uniquely compelling. By presenting multiple works together, these lists offer broader contexts and encourage readers to explore connections between seemingly disparate creations.

Exploring Artistic Depth: A Focus on Visual Storytelling

Amy Sherald's painting 'Midsummer Afternoon Dream' exemplifies the fusion of tradition and innovation in visual art. Through her signature grisaille technique, Sherald paints skin tones in shades of gray, creating a stark contrast with the vibrant hues of clothing and backgrounds. This method draws inspiration from classical portraiture while incorporating bold palettes reminiscent of post-Impressionist artists like Matisse. Such juxtapositions enrich the narrative depth of her work, making even simple scenes feel profound and timeless.

Moreover, the inclusion of personal details—such as Amy's own dog perched in a bicycle basket—adds layers of intimacy and relatability to the piece. Set against the backdrop of Fort Tilden, a location steeped in history yet now serving as a serene retreat, the painting bridges past and present. It reminds viewers that everyday moments deserve artistic recognition just as much as grand historical events. Thus, Sherald's work not only captivates visually but also invites contemplation on the value of documenting ordinary life through extraordinary means.