In this year-end reflection, film critic Amy Nicholson shares her insights on the standout movies of 2024. As awards season approaches, Nicholson highlights films that have left a lasting impact, such as the ambitious "Dune: Part Two" and the daring "Anora." She also discusses movies that missed the mark, including "The Garfield Movie," offering a critical yet engaging analysis of what made these films succeed or falter.

The Ambitious and Intelligent Adaptations

Amy Nicholson praises films that push the boundaries of storytelling and filmmaking. One such example is "Dune: Part Two," which she commends for its grand vision and intelligent adaptation of Frank Herbert's science fiction classic. Nicholson emphasizes how the film goes beyond a mere retelling, delving into the core elements that make the story relevant today.

Nicholson believes that "Dune: Part Two" stands out due to its ability to capture the essence of the original work while presenting it in a way that resonates with contemporary audiences. The film's ambitious scale and thoughtful execution set it apart as a cinematic achievement. Nicholson notes that the movie not only honors the source material but also introduces new layers of meaning, making it a compelling watch for both fans and newcomers alike. The director's approach to adapting the novel ensures that viewers are fully immersed in the world of Dune, appreciating its depth and complexity.

Characters That Resonate and Stories That Surprise

Another highlight from Nicholson's list is "Anora," a modern retelling that centers around a New York exotic dancer played by Mikey Madison. Nicholson admires the protagonist's emotional depth and resilience, noting how Madison brings a fresh perspective to the Cinderella narrative. The character's fearlessness and humor add an unexpected twist to the familiar tale, making it a standout performance.

Nicholson expresses her belief that Madison's portrayal of Anora could earn significant recognition during awards season. The film challenges traditional narratives by placing a sex worker at the center of the story, showcasing her strength and determination. This unconventional approach adds layers to the character, allowing audiences to connect with her struggles and triumphs. Nicholson also touches on some of the year's disappointments, such as "The Garfield Movie," which failed to meet expectations. She critiques the casting choice and the departure from the beloved comic strip, highlighting how important it is for adaptations to stay true to their roots.