When it comes to the portrayal of New York City in films, there have been significant changes over the years. From the "A Complete Unknown" with its 1960s Greenwich Village charm to the "Anora" set in present-day Brooklyn, filmmakers have continuously reimagined the city. As a teenager, I was captivated by the movies that showed a New York within reach, where one could bring big dreams and a few suitcases. These weren't the typical action-packed films but rather stories of plucky heroines in tree-lined streets, donning heels and pencil skirts for their magazine jobs. I envied the dinner parties in creaky, book-filled homes, the pastrami on rye downtown, and the piles of books clutched by characters alongside rumpled copies of a certain New York newspaper. New York seemed aspirational, magical, and fun. However, this particular version of the metropolis has almost disappeared from Hollywood's imagination in recent years.

The Impact of Changing Times on New York City in Films

In 2024, it is evident that the way we watch New York has transformed. A stroll around Lower Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn reveals a landscape that resembles an Instagram feed, with stores selling cool minimalist clothing and pebbled leather bags. These streets, once a staple on the big screen, are now the domain of vertical video and social media. This shift has had interesting effects on movies. Filmmakers are now putting different frames around the city, often depicting a city that has since vanished.

The Success of "A Complete Unknown" in Evoking the Past

James Mangold's "A Complete Unknown" about Bob Dylan's early career is perhaps the standout. It successfully evokes the color and texture of the 1960s on the streets of Greenwich Village. By carefully reconstructing the setting and using rich camerawork, it brings to life a dirty, exciting New York filled with chaos, smoke, and endless possibilities down every coffeehouse staircase. The attention to detail is remarkable, making the audience feel like they are transported back in time. This film showcases how filmmakers can recreate a bygone era with authenticity and charm.

The Present-Day Brooklyn in "Anora"

In contrast to the 1960s setting of "A Complete Unknown", "Anora" takes us to present-day Brooklyn. It presents a different side of the city, with its modern architecture and diverse neighborhoods. The film explores the essence of Brooklyn in this era, highlighting the unique culture and lifestyle that make it a vibrant place. It shows how the city has evolved while still retaining its essence. Through the eyes of the characters, we get a glimpse of the daily lives and struggles in present-day Brooklyn, making it a relatable and engaging story.

The Disappearance of the Old New York from Hollywood

The almost complete disappearance of the old New York from Hollywood's imagination is a sad reality. While New York still appears on screen, it is often a different city, one that doesn't capture the essence of the past. The focus has shifted towards more modern and trendy settings, leaving behind the nostalgic charm of the old New York. This loss is felt by those who remember the city as it once was and by filmmakers who strive to capture its true spirit. It is a reminder of how quickly things change and how important it is to preserve the history and culture of a city like New York.