Unraveling the Success and Struggles of Fall's Movie Adaptations
"The Wild Robot": A Tale Transformed
Based on Peter Brown's book, "The Wild Robot" is a standout among this season's adaptations. It takes full advantage of the power of the movie medium, specifically through the use of point of view. By allowing us to see the world through the eyes of the title character, Roz, a robot who befriends various creatures after crashing into this world, we are able to connect with the story on a deeper level. The themes of parenthood, climate crisis, and friendship are beautifully elaborated in the gorgeous, animated film, making it one of the best movies of the year.
The movie showcases how the movie form can enhance and expand upon the themes found in the book. It brings the story to life in a way that is both visually stunning and emotionally engaging, leaving audiences with a lasting impression.
"Conclave": Transforming the Vatican Drama
"Conclave" is another adaptation that surpasses its source material. It not only shows us remarkable aspects that the book had to tell us about but also creates a vivid illusion of Vatican City through its production design. The film follows the priests and one nun as they zip around the Vatican, scheming to influence the selection of a new pope. This adds an extra layer of excitement and intrigue to the story.
The attention to detail in recreating the Vatican setting and the tension-filled plot make "Conclave" a captivating viewing experience. It demonstrates how adaptations can enhance and expand upon the original story, offering a fresh take on a familiar theme.
"Here": The Challenges of a Plotless Adaptation
Writer/director Robert Zemeckis' "Here" reunites him with "Forrest Gump" stars Tom Hanks and Robin Wright. However, unlike the other adaptations, "Here" has no plot and few real characters. It focuses instead on a single place and the various people and animals that inhabit it over centuries.
While the concept is interesting, especially in terms of exploring our own spaces and the history that lies within them, the movie struggles to translate the unique form of the graphic novel onto the big screen. The confined space and stationary camera make it feel more like a play than a movie, and the actors often overact as if trying to reach the back row of a theater.
"Wicked": Balancing Musical and Novel
"Wicked", based on both the Broadway musical and Gregory Maguire's novel, is more successful than "Here" in its adaptation. It incorporates more of the novel's elements than the musical did, creating a more comprehensive story. While it may feel overly theatrical at times, it still manages to capture the essence of the source material.
The adaptation shows how different forms of storytelling can be combined to create a unique and engaging experience. It highlights the importance of honoring the original while also making necessary changes to suit the medium of film.