This spring, MCC Theater is celebrating a quarter-century of its annual "Miscast" gala, an event that brings together some of Broadway’s brightest stars to perform songs they wouldn’t traditionally be cast in. The occasion has inspired a new album, set for release on March 28, featuring performances by luminaries such as Lea Salonga, Heather Headley, and Jonathan Groff. These artists reinterpret iconic musical numbers in unexpected ways, offering fresh perspectives and showcasing their versatility. The project highlights the transformative power of music while reflecting evolving trends in casting.
The album captures not only the humor but also the emotional depth of these unconventional renditions. From Rachel Zegler’s take on “Who I’d Be” from “Shrek” to Kelli O’Hara’s tender rendition of “Beautiful City” from “Godspell,” each track reveals something unique about both the performer and the song itself. This celebration marks a significant milestone in MCC Theater's history, emphasizing its role in pushing boundaries within the world of musical theater.
Breaking Boundaries Through Unconventional Performances
The essence of "Miscast" lies in its ability to challenge traditional norms surrounding casting. Artists like Rachel Zegler, who reimagines Shrek's heartfelt ballad, and Heather Headley, who steps into Simba's shoes with “Endless Night,” demonstrate how gender, age, and even species can be transcended through artistry. By inviting performers to step outside their usual roles, MCC Theater encourages them to explore new facets of their craft, resulting in interpretations that are both surprising and deeply moving.
Scott Galina, manager of musical programming at MCC, explains that the performances range from lighthearted and playful to profoundly impactful. For instance, Aaron Tveit and Gavin Creel’s rendition of “Take Me or Leave Me” from “Rent” resonates all the more poignantly following Creel’s passing last year. Similarly, Ben Platt channels Elphaba in “The Wizard and I,” while Eva Noblezada flexes her vocal muscles in “Go the Distance.” These examples illustrate how stepping beyond conventional boundaries allows performers to breathe new life into familiar tunes. As Will Van Dyke, the musical director, notes, every track on the album offers listeners an experience worth savoring.
A Legacy of Evolution and Inclusivity
Beyond the individual performances, "Miscast" serves as a testament to the changing landscape of Broadway. Over the past two decades, there has been a noticeable shift toward more inclusive casting practices, influenced in part by events like this gala. Gender-swapped productions, such as Stephen Sondheim’s “Company,” highlight the growing acceptance of non-traditional interpretations. MCC Theater’s commitment to fostering diversity and innovation ensures that its platform remains relevant and inspiring for future generations.
As part of its 25th anniversary celebrations, MCC Theater will host a live gala at the Hammerstein Ballroom on April 7, honoring trailblazers like Sheryl Lee Ralph and Travis Raeburn. Attendees can look forward to dynamic performances by talents including Tituss Burgess, Nicole Scherzinger, and Phillipa Soo. Proceeds from both the gala and the accompanying album support MCC Theater’s ongoing mission to nurture emerging artists and promote inclusivity in the arts. This legacy underscores the importance of embracing change and encouraging creativity, ensuring that the spirit of "Miscast" continues to thrive long into the future.