Serena Pitt and Joe Amabile's love story is one that continues to captivate. Married since 2022, their romance shows no signs of fading. Pitt, at 27, shares with PEOPLE at the Warner Bros. Fall TV Celebration with Fenty Beauty how Amabile, 38, still surprises her with presents. "There's so many things about him that I thought may die off after the honeymoon stage," Pitt says. "Joe still just continues to surprise me with little gifts and thoughtful gestures and that really is who he is, and I love that."

A Married Couple's Endless Surprises

Marriage Milestones

The couple met on season 7 of Bachelor in Paradise and got married. First, they had a courthouse wedding in Oct. 2022. Then, in Sept. 2023, they celebrated with a Charleston, South Carolina, ceremony with friends and family. Pitt and Amabile admit that having two wedding anniversaries can be a bit much at times. "We don't know which one to celebrate," Pitt says. Amabile jokes back, "That's what comes with going on reality TV and meeting."

This journey of marriage has had its unique moments, from the initial excitement to the present-day coziness.

They have navigated through these different stages with grace and love.

Holiday Plans

The couple tells PEOPLE about their cozy holiday plans. According to Pitt, "Joe's obsessed with Christmas." She shares that he sends her Christmas reels on Instagram all year long and plays Christmas music all year long. They decided to celebrate Canadian Thanksgiving with Pitt's family in October and U.S. Thanksgiving with Amabile's family. After Christmas, they'll head to Costa Rica. They both want to focus on enjoying the holidays and "the good things."

These holiday plans add a special touch to their married life.

It shows their shared interests and the importance they place on spending time together.

Married Life at Jill Zarin's

Earlier this year, at Jill Zarin's luxury luncheon at Southampton Inn in New York on July 20, the married couple talked about their "chill" married life. Pitt said, "You know what? It's really same old, same old." Amabile agreed, "Everything's good. It's very chill, which is good."

This moment gave a glimpse into their daily lives together.

It showed that their love has translated into a comfortable and peaceful marriage.