Television
Television QA: The Debate Over Laugh Tracks in Shows
2024-12-08
Have you ever found yourself in a situation where a show's element disrupted your viewing experience? Or perhaps you were left wondering about the fate of a beloved character? Here, we aim to provide answers to your questions and shed light on various aspects of your favorite shows.

Unraveling the Mysteries of Your Favorite Shows

Q: The Annoying Laugh Track in “Happy Place”

You might have enjoyed the cast and storyline of the new show “Happy Place,” but the annoying laugh track might have made you consider stopping watching. It doesn't seem realistic as it occurs too often and sometimes at inappropriate times, interrupting the conversations and the flow of the dialog. Many other popular comedy shows don't use it, so you might wonder why the people in charge think it's necessary. Just look at “The Big Bang Theory” which had laughter while its prequel, “Young Sheldon,” did not, and the in-between story of “Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage” has what seems more like a chuckle track. The laughter you hear could be pre-recorded, from the show's studio audience, or a combination of both. As Jennifer Keishin Armstrong wrote on BBC.com some years back, producers often want “some sort of audience reaction to make the viewing experience more communal,” like in a theater. On the other hand, TV veteran (and former U.S. senator) Al Franken once told the Chicago Tribune that an inserted laugh is “like putting a bookmark for the audience saying, ‘That was a joke.’” But did they get the joke? Charley Douglass, the sound engineer credited with the first use of pre-recorded laughs, “hated that the studio audiences on the U.S. TV channels’ shows laughed at the wrong moments, didn’t laugh at the right moments, or laughed too loudly or for too long.” This led to the birth of an electronic companion and the ongoing debate.

Q: The Future of “A Man on the Inside”

You really enjoyed the first season of “A Man on the Inside” with Ted Danson as an undercover spy in a retirement home. Now, you're wondering if there will be a second season. Like you, we want one too. Danson told the Hollywood Reporter in late October that “Netflix has its system, so we won’t know (about a renewal) for a month, but we seem to be doing really well.” And series creator Mike Schur said the show was pitched “as a series, not a limited thing. … Before the season was even over, we had started saying [a second season] could be this, could be this, and trying to figure out how it would be different and how it would be the same. He can’t go undercover at Pacific View anymore. Obviously, that ship has sailed. But what you have at the end of the season is a 76-year-old man with a new lease on life and a new sense of purpose and a new kind of fledgling career as an undercover detective. You have a lot of building blocks for future seasons.

Q: Grace's Departure from “9-1-1: Lone Star”

According to Deadline.com, Sierra McClain, who played Grace Ryder on the series, left the show “following some cast renegotiation drama.” Cast members reportedly sought changes in their contracts as the drama started work on its current, fifth (and final) season, but were told there would be no renegotiations, just some cash bonuses. While many cast members came back, McClain did not. On the show, Grace was sent off to work for a Christian charity, and some of this season has involved how her absence has affected her husband Judd (Jim Parrack).

Q: The Film “Hostiles”

You might be thinking of the terrific film “Hostiles” from 2017 starring Christian Bale as a soldier tasked with taking a Native American chief into custody. Along the way, he rescued a woman whose entire family had been killed by a tribe. Scott Cooper wrote and directed it, and besides Bale the cast included Rosamund Pike and Wes Studi. It is available for free on Tubi and for a fee on Prime Video, Apple TV, Plex and Fandango at Home.(Write to Rich Heldenfels, P.O. Box 417, Mogadore, OH 44260, or brenfels@gmail.com.)
More Stories
see more