Movies
Top 10 Hallmark Christmas Movies Ranked by Reviews
2024-12-12
Hallmark Christmas movies have become an integral part of holiday traditions. While classics like “White Christmas” and “Scrooged” are enjoyable, these movies hold a special place. Forbes has ranked the best Hallmark Christmas movies based on reviews from various sites. Let's take a closer look at the top 10 and how to watch them.

Uncover the Magic of Hallmark Christmas Movies

10. “The Holiday Sitter”

Sam, a workaholic bachelor, finds himself babysitting his niece and nephew during the holidays. Out of his comfort zone, he enlists the help of a handsome neighbor and embarks on an unexpected romance. One reviewer on Rotten Tomatoes praised, "Hallmark actually put some time and effort into this movie and it shows. A great story with strong actors really helped — even the supporting cast were terrific." This movie is accessible for streaming on Hallmark+ and Hoopla. It can also be purchased via on-demand services like Apple TV and Amazon Prime for just $5.

It offers a heartwarming tale that showcases the charm of holiday babysitting and the possibility of finding love in unexpected places. The chemistry between the characters is palpable, making it a delightful watch.

The movie's setting during the holidays adds an extra layer of warmth and coziness. It's a perfect choice for those looking for a light-hearted and romantic holiday film.

9. “Christmas with Holly”

The owner of a toy store falls in love with a man who takes care of his orphaned niece. One reviewer on Rotten Tomatoes shared, "I must have cried three times with this movie." This movie is available for streaming on Hallmark+ and Hoopla.

The story of love and connection in a holiday setting is truly touching. It highlights the power of love and the magic that can happen during the holidays.

The characters are well-developed, and the chemistry between the lead actors is evident. It's a movie that will tug at your heartstrings and leave you with a warm feeling.

8. “My Christmas Family Tree”

A woman discovers her family tree during the holidays and meets her long-lost relatives for the first time. One reviewer on IMDb mentioned, "This one is one of the best. What I liked about it the most is it’s not all about the romance, that’s more the secondary story and it actually has a story." This movie is available to stream on Hallmark+. It will also be aired on the Hallmark Channel at 8 a.m. on Dec. 12 and 4:01 a.m. on Dec. 22.

The exploration of family and heritage during the holidays is a unique aspect of this movie. It shows that there is more to the holiday season than just romance.

The characters' journeys of discovery and reunion are both heartwarming and inspiring. It's a movie that celebrates the importance of family.

7. “The Holiday Stocking”

A new angel gets the opportunity to address his one regret — not helping his sisters reconcile during his lifetime. Returning as a stranger, he helps them revive their parents' old tradition of encouraging charity. One reviewer on Rotten Tomatoes said, "One of my favorites this past….The characters seemed very real to me, and it was such a heartfelt story line." This movie is available for streaming on Hallmark+ and Hoopla.

The theme of redemption and the power of family traditions is beautifully portrayed in this movie. It shows that even in the afterlife, one can make a difference.

The performances of the actors are outstanding, bringing the characters to life and making the story feel authentic. It's a movie that will leave you with a sense of hope.

6. “A Royal Christmas”

A queen schemes to break up her son's romance with a seamstress from Philadelphia. One reviewer on IMDb commented, "This is the perfect Christmas movie that is well written, well acted, and the soundtrack is perfect." This movie is available for streaming on Hallmark+ and Hoopla. It will also be aired on the Hallmark Channel at 10 p.m. on Dec. 19.

The royal setting adds a touch of grandeur to the holiday story. It's a classic tale of love and family with a royal twist.

The performances of the cast are top-notch, making you believe in the love story between the lead characters. The soundtrack enhances the holiday mood and adds to the overall charm of the movie.

5. “Christmas Under Wraps”

After moving to Alaska unexpectedly, an ambitious doctor starts a new romance and discovers a holiday secret in her small town. One reviewer on IMDb stated, "Really nice and unpretentious Christmas romance. No convoluted “problems” with the love interests, for a change." This movie is available for streaming on Hallmark+ and Hoopla. It can also be purchased on-demand for $5. It will be aired on the Hallmark Channel at 10 p.m. on Dec. 18.

The setting of Alaska during Christmas gives the movie a unique and picturesque backdrop. It's a story about finding love and community in a new place.

The simplicity of the love story is refreshing. It focuses on the genuine connection between the characters rather than unnecessary drama. It's a feel-good movie that will put you in the holiday spirit.

4. “A Christmas Love Story”

A youth choir director must write the title song for the Christmas Eve show but gets distracted when a gifted boy joins her choir without his widowed father's knowledge. One reviewer on IMDb said, "I enjoyed this movie. The story had many well-used elements, but I liked the way it was put together. I probably should have seen it coming, but I didn’t anticipate the ‘twist’ until the last minute."

The combination of music and holiday romance is a winning formula in this movie. It shows the power of music to bring people together.

The characters' growth and the unexpected twists add depth to the story. It's a movie that keeps you engaged from start to finish.

3. “Take Me Back for Christmas”

A Christmas wish grants Renée the successful life she's always dreamed of, but she finds herself no longer married to her beloved husband. One reviewer on Rotten Tomatoes mentioned, "The acting was better than most in this genre. More importantly, the story was sweet and showcased the importance of cherishing every moment we have with those we love." This movie is available for streaming on Hallmark+ and Hoopla.

The movie explores the theme of lost love and the value of treasuring the present. It's a story that will make you reflect on your own relationships.

The performances are heartfelt, and the chemistry between the characters is evident. It's a movie that will touch your heart and leave you with a message of love and gratitude.

2. “Three Wise Men and a Baby”

Three brothers are surprised when they are forced to work together and care for a baby during the holidays. One reviewer on Rotten Tomatoes said, "I loved it! I’m not usually a Hallmark movies watching kind of person, but I could see this becoming a regular Xmas tradition. These guys are fabulous together." This movie is free to stream on Hallmark+ and Hoopla. It can also be purchased on some on-demand services for $5. It will be aired on the Hallmark Channel at 4 p.m. on Dec. 12, noon on Dec. 14, midnight on Dec. 17, 10 p.m. on Dec. 23, noon on Christmas Day, and the extended cut at 8 p.m. on Dec. 22.

The story of three brothers coming together to care for a baby is both heartwarming and humorous. It shows the power of family and the joy of the holiday season.

The chemistry between the brothers is infectious, and their interactions with the baby are adorable. It's a movie that will bring a smile to your face.

1. “A Biltmore Christmas”

A magical hourglass sends a modern-day screenwriter to the set of a 1947 holiday movie classic. Before she can return to the present, she must make things right or risk altering the future forever. One reviewer on Rotten Tomatoes said, "If you love rom coms and Christmas, this is a must watch. I was so surprised at how touching and magical it was. It’s also a little silly and perfectly cheesy." This movie is available for streaming on Netflix, Fubo, and Hallmark+. It will also be aired on the Hallmark Channel at 8 a.m. on Dec. 17.

The combination of magic and Christmas in a movie set is a unique concept. It takes you on a journey through time and emotions.

The performances are excellent, and the story is both entertaining and thought-provoking. It's a movie that will leave you with a sense of wonder.

How to sign up for Hallmark+

If you want to watch all the Hallmark Christmas movies at your convenience, signing up for the Hallmark+ streaming service is the best option. There is a one-week free trial, a monthly plan for about $8 per month, and an annual plan for about $80 per year.

In addition to the extensive movie/TV show library, subscribers also get a $5 monthly Gold Crown coupon that can be used at participating stores and online. They also enjoy unlimited eCards, a free custom greeting card every month, and more perks.

Miguel Legoas is a Deep South Connect Team Reporter for Gannett/USA Today. Find him on X and Instagram @miguelegoas and email atmlegoas@gannett.com.
More Stories
see more